ACI-CD16 Part 3: From Prototype to Production

ACI-CD16 16-channel DCC current detector in its grey 3D-printed enclosure with black base, showing ventilation slots, configuration jumpers and green track connection terminals.

The final chapter in the development of ACI Model Railways’ 16-channel DCC current detector.

Developing a new product rarely follows a perfectly straight path. What begins as a circuit diagram and a list of requirements gradually becomes something physical. Only when the hardware is assembled, tested and installed do the smaller details begin to reveal themselves.

That has certainly been our experience with the ACI-CD16.

In Part One, Why ACI Built a Model Railway Current Detector, we explained how our experience with the Holgate exhibition layout led us to develop a dedicated 16-channel detection system. In Part Two, ACI-CD16 Prototype Testing Begins, we covered the first detection and communication tests, along with issues identified during early testing.

Since then, the PCB design has been revised, the enclosure has gone through numerous iterations, and the detector has become part of our demonstration system. This final development article brings those stages together.

Revisiting the PCB Design

The first ACI-CD16 prototype demonstrated the fundamental approach: current drawn by a locomotive could be detected, an individual channel LED could provide local indication, and occupancy information could be communicated to DCC-EX over I²C.

However, the first successful test was not the end of development. Extended testing revealed components operating warmer than we considered acceptable. Rather than ignore the issue, we revisited the circuitry and component choices as part of the next PCB revision.

The changes produced a substantial reduction in heat generation. During subsequent testing, the affected components operated at temperatures lower than we had originally expected for normal operation. That was an important step towards a design we could be confident in using on a layout.

Confirming Detection and Communication

We then returned to the practical tests that matter most to a modeller. The revised current detector was tested repeatedly on a test layout, consistently detecting occupancy and successfully reporting that information back to the DCC-EX command station.

We also tested I²C communications and the selectable addressing arrangements, confirming that the command station could receive the detector's information using the configured address. Together, these tests established that the PCB revisions had addressed the temperature concern without compromising the core detection and communication functions.

Throughout this work, the objectives remained unchanged: sixteen independent detection channels, visible local indications, configurable I²C addressing and straightforward connections to the layout. Retaining the established board dimensions and connector arrangement also allowed enclosure development to proceed alongside the electronics.

The important lesson was that a prototype proving the concept is not the same thing as a finished product. The revised design had to be considered not just electrically, but as hardware that would eventually be installed beneath a model railway.

Designing an Enclosure Around the PCB

We decided that the CD16 deserved a purpose-designed enclosure rather than simply leaving the electronics exposed. Under a model railway baseboard, a detector may be surrounded by wiring, fixing hardware and other accessories. Protection matters, but so does access for installation and fault-finding.

The CD16 PCB measures approximately 110 × 90 mm. Its enclosure therefore needed to accommodate the board while keeping the terminal connections, addressing jumpers and sixteen indicator LEDs accessible or visible.

We developed the design in OpenSCAD, using a parametric model so that dimensions and features could be adjusted without starting again after each test print.

ACI-CD16 current detector enclosure showing ventilation slots, terminal connections and configuration access openings
The purpose-designed ACI-CD16 enclosure, developed through several iterations.

From CAD Model to Physical Enclosure

The first designs established the overall footprint, base and lid. Once printed, however, the physical parts revealed details that were less obvious on screen.

Some mounting pillars needed repositioning to align comfortably with the PCB holes. Clearance around the board and case walls also required adjustment. We made these changes incrementally, checking each revision against the actual circuit board rather than relying on the CAD model alone.

PCB Supports and Lid Fixings

Internal pillars raise the PCB above the enclosure base. We also reconsidered how the lid should be secured. An early snap-fit approach gave way to a screw-secured design, with the fixings accessed from underneath the case and a locating lip helping the lid sit correctly.

This is a small change in appearance but a meaningful improvement for a product that may need to be opened for inspection or maintenance.

Terminal Access, Addressing and Indicators

The enclosure had to remain practical once installed. We refined the openings around the terminal areas, provided access to the configuration jumpers and incorporated a viewing opening for the row of channel LEDs.

Those LEDs are particularly useful during installation: they provide immediate local feedback when a detection section is occupied, without needing to consult a separate screen.

Side view of the ACI-CD16 16-channel current detector showing the grey enclosure and accessible green track terminal connectors
The enclosure provides protection for the PCB while retaining access to the track connections and configuration points.

Ventilation and Designing for 3D Printing

As the case evolved, we added ventilation features and considered the space beneath the PCB. The vent openings required several revisions to their position and angle.

Some early geometries created overhangs that the slicing software identified as requiring support material. We adjusted the vent design to make it better suited to FDM printing, reducing unnecessary supports while retaining the intended openings.

The base also incorporates keyhole-style fixing points to help secure the enclosure beneath a layout. Taken together, these details make the difference between a box that merely fits and a case designed for practical use.

Materials and Print Quality

Much of the enclosure prototyping was carried out in PLA because it allowed us to check fit and dimensions quickly. Test printing also revealed issues such as surface finish, corner adhesion and the difficulty of removing supports cleanly from recessed areas.

For the finished enclosure, we have been working towards PETG as a practical material choice, with useful toughness and temperature resistance for an electronics housing. Our aim is a durable case that can be produced consistently, not simply one that looks good in a rendering.

Bringing the CD16 into the Demonstration Layout

The purpose of the CD16 has always been to provide useful information about where trains are on a layout. Our demonstration system brings that purpose into focus.

At its centre is the ACI CSB1 command station running DCC-EX. The demonstration layout combines a DCC-operated section with current detection, servo-operated accessories and working signals. It also includes a separate DC-operated section using relay hardware and the DCC-EX Nodes approach.

Both the DC and DCC sections are controlled by the same CSB1. This is an important part of what we want to demonstrate: DCC-EX is capable of much more than simply supplying track power.

From Detection to Action

When a locomotive draws current in an isolated detection section, the CD16 can report that section as occupied. Its channel LED provides local confirmation, while the occupancy state is communicated over I²C to DCC-EX.

EX-RAIL can use that information as part of the operating logic: for example, to check whether a section is occupied before permitting a movement, or to coordinate a route with points and signals. The exact behaviour depends on the automation written for the layout.

Our goal is to show visitors a working system in which train control, detection and accessories operate together, without requiring a computer to remain connected during normal operation.

More Than a Current Detector

The CD16 also illustrates the direction in which we are developing the ACI range. The CSB1 provides train control, the CD16 provides track occupancy information, and the developing ACI-S16 servo decoder adds accessory-control capabilities.

Each board serves a distinct purpose. Used together with DCC-EX and EX-RAIL, however, they provide building blocks for more capable model railway operation and automation.

What We Learned

Three lessons stand out from the project. First, a successful first test is only the beginning: the thermal behaviour of the prototype needed further attention. Second, enclosure design is engineering in its own right, involving access, clearances, mounting and manufacturing constraints. Third, testing hardware as part of a real model railway is essential if the finished product is to solve real modelling problems.

The CD16 began with the practical requirements of Holgate. That same focus has guided the PCB revisions, the enclosure design and the work on our demonstration layout.

The Next Chapter for ACI

We plan to demonstrate the wider system at the National Festival of Railway Modelling at the NEC, Birmingham, on 21–22 November 2026. Visitors will be able to see how the CSB1, current detection, accessory control and automation fit together.

Holgate showed us why the project was necessary. For a command station to make useful decisions about train movements, it needs dependable information about which sections of the layout are occupied. Current detectors were already available, but none met the particular combination of requirements we had identified for Holgate and its DCC-EX control system. Rather than adapt the layout around those limitations, we set out to develop the detector the layout needed.

The result is more than a working 16-channel PCB in a purpose-designed enclosure. The ACI-CD16 adds an essential source of occupancy information to the growing ACI ecosystem, alongside the CSB1 command station and our developing accessory-control hardware. It gives DCC-EX and EX-RAIL information they can act upon, bringing us closer to a coordinated system of train detection, movement and control.

Although the CD16 was developed with DCC-EX in mind, we are also thinking beyond today's installation. As DCC-EX continues to develop, and as we explore opportunities for other compatible systems to make use of the detector, we want the hardware to remain a useful foundation for what comes next. That is a direction for future development, rather than a claim of compatibility we have not yet established.

From identifying a problem on Holgate to revising the electronics, validating detection and communication, and refining the enclosure, this project has been driven by a simple principle: build the hardware around the needs of the layout.

The ACI-CD16 began as a way for Holgate to tell the command station where a train was. It now forms part of our wider vision for what model railway control can become.


Follow the ACI-CD16 Development Series

The ACI-CD16 is independently developed by ACI Model Railways for use with compatible layout-control systems, including DCC-EX.